Soot after a fire: commercial cleaning methods compared

Soot after a fire: commercial cleaning methods compared

Reading Time: 8 min.

Removing soot after a fire means taking off soot deposits and the fire residues bound to them from walls, ceilings, floors and building components without spreading them through the building and without damaging the surface. In commercial properties there is a second requirement: operations should resume as quickly as possible. With the vacuum blasting method of the Tornado ACS, systeco offers a process that works without water, without chemicals and without high pressure.

This article is written for facility managers, property managers, site managers and restoration companies. It describes what remains in a building after a fire, which first steps have proven useful, how the common methods differ and where vacuum blasting has its limits.

What remains in the building after a fire

Once the fire is out, fire residues remain. In its guidance C 318 Brandschadensanierung, the German employers' liability insurance association BG BAU lists hazardous substances bound to fire condensates and soot, hazardous substances from production and storage stock, hazardous substances from the building fabric and biological agents. It treats fire damage restoration as work in contaminated areas.

This has two consequences. First, soot is more than a cosmetic problem: it contains substances that are harmful to health and can reach the room air if handled incorrectly. Second, the damage often extends beyond the room that burned. In VdS 3400, the German property insurers point out that smoke and fire residues can lead to costly cleaning, late corrosion damage and business interruption even in areas the fire itself did not reach.

First steps: secure, assess, document

Before cleaning starts, the damage has to be recorded. This order has proven useful in practice:

  1. Secure the area. Seal off affected rooms so that soot is not carried into other areas along walkways and ventilation.
  2. Record and document the damage. Photograph affected areas, surfaces and use. The insurer will need this documentation later.
  3. Assess the hazards. Which protective measures are required in each case is determined by the risk assessment of the contractor performing the work; BG BAU refers to TRGS 524 and DGUV Regel 101-004. The insurers' guidelines on restoration are set out in VdS 2357; they are non-binding.
  4. Choose the method. Only now is it decided how to clean (see below).
  5. Clean and sign off. Check and document the result before surfaces are painted or put back into use.

Who pays depends on the case. According to systeco, the building insurance covers the cost of fire damage restoration in most cases; where third parties are affected, the liability insurance of the party responsible may step in. The overview of fire damage restoration explains this.

Methods compared

What happens to the soot when it is treated dry, wet or by blasting? The key differences:

  • Dry, with a broom or vacuum cleaner. systeco strongly advises against this on its page about soot removal after fire: the soot contains substances that are harmful to health and is stirred up and spread through the surroundings.
  • Wet, with water, brush and cleaning agents. This has its pitfalls too. Carcinogenic substances can penetrate into the plaster and can hardly be removed completely this way. Wastewater and chemicals are added to the problem.
  • High pressure or dry ice blasting. According to systeco, these methods often reach their limits with soot and can burden the building fabric and the environment. The pages alternative to the high-pressure cleaner and alternative to dry ice blasting explain the differences.
  • Vacuum blasting. The blasting medium is accelerated onto the surface by negative pressure and extracted immediately. The soot stays in the closed circuit of the machine and is captured in the filter system. No wastewater is produced and no chemicals are used.

Which surface needs what

What matters is how sensitive the surface is and how deep the soot sits. According to systeco, vacuum blasting removes soot and other fire residues from clinker, concrete, plaster, natural stone and tiles; on its reference pages systeco also shows ceilings, basement ceilings and wood. The blasting media table shows which medium suits which surface.

The blasting media overview from systeco assigns the media to surfaces as follows:

  • Light, sensitive surfaces such as external thermal insulation, plaster, paint, natural stone and clinker: fine blasting glass (SG 150).
  • Light, hard surfaces such as floor tiles, well-fired clinker, concrete, hardwood and granite: blasting glass SG 300.
  • Dark surfaces such as clinker, natural stone and concrete: Asilit AS 180; the coarser Asilit AS 250 is intended for hard natural stone and well-fired clinker and can cause damage on sensitive substrates.
  • Polished surfaces such as marble and granite: walnut shell NS 450.

The blasting medium determines how gently the surface is treated. According to systeco it is reused up to 100 times in the circuit. The same principle applies to facades and exterior surfaces, as described in the overview of vacuum blasting.

Vacuum blasting after a fire: process and limits

The blasting hood is placed on the sooty surface and holds on by negative pressure. The blasting lance directs the medium onto the surface at up to 400 km/h; the effect resembles very fine grinding that removes the soiled layer. Blasting medium and removed material are extracted immediately. The process can be monitored through the viewing windows in the hood.

For sensitive interiors, systeco has offered an optional HEPA filter of class H13 since 2018; according to systeco it retains up to 99.9 percent of the removed particles. The machine needs a normal power connection and, according to systeco, is light and compact.

The limits are part of the picture:

  • Area performance. For fire damage restoration systeco states roughly 2 to 5 square metres per hour. Large areas need time and planning accordingly.
  • Dry surfaces, tightly sealing hood. The method only works on dry surfaces with a hood that sits cleanly on the surface. Unevenness larger than 15 to 25 millimetres requires special attachments.
  • Soft substances. Chewing gum and similar soft materials cannot be removed.
  • The individual case. How deep fire condensate has penetrated a substrate and which measures the risk assessment requires is clarified by the on-site damage survey, not by a method alone.

Restoring while operations continue

Many businesses cannot shut down a hall, a warehouse or a food production area for weeks. According to systeco, the cost of halting production is usually very high. Because vacuum blasting produces no water, no chemicals and no dust cloud, and the residues stay in the closed circuit, sections can be worked on while the rest of the operation continues. systeco describes jobs in a bakery in Austria and in a basement; details are on the page fire damage restoration at running operation and in the overview of fire damage restoration.

In practice this means: seal off areas, agree the order of surfaces with the operation and document the sign-off for each area. Which protective measures apply to staff is determined by the contractor in the risk assessment.

What decision-makers should clarify beforehand

The manufacturer's data and the guidelines give a short checklist for the conversation with the restoration company:

  • Surfaces and degree of soiling. Which materials are affected, how deep does the soot sit, and which medium fits (see above)?
  • Area and time. At the area performance of 2 to 5 square metres per hour stated by systeco, 100 square metres means roughly 20 to 50 hours of pure blasting time. This is a calculation from the manufacturer's figures, not a promise; the real effort is determined by the damage survey.
  • Operations. Which areas must be usable first, which can stay sealed off?
  • Insurer and assessor. Involve them early and agree documentation and sign-off.
  • Risk assessment. Who prepares it, and which protective measures follow from it (BG BAU C 318)?
  • Disposal. According to systeco, the removed residues stay in the closed circuit until the end of the work and are then disposed of in an environmentally compliant way.

After the soot is removed

Once the soot is removed, the condition is signed off and documented. Only then do painting, repairs and the return to operation follow. For follow-up work on natural stone, clinker or concrete, the special applications section helps.

Anyone who wants to check whether the method suits their property can get advice via the contact page. The method and the technology behind it are described on the pages about the Tornado ACS and eco-friendly cleaning technology.

FAQ: Soot after a fire in commercial buildings

Is soot after a fire harmful to health?

Yes, according to systeco soot contains substances that are harmful to health. BG BAU describes fire damage restoration as work in contaminated areas and refers to the risk assessment. Which protective measures are required is determined by the contractor performing the work.

May I remove soot with a broom or vacuum cleaner?

systeco strongly advises against it. The soot is stirred up and spread through the surroundings. Even cleaning with water, brush and cleaning agents can hardly remove carcinogenic substances that may penetrate into the plaster completely.

Which methods exist for soot removal in commercial buildings?

Common are dry cleaning, wet cleaning with cleaning agents, high pressure, dry ice blasting and vacuum blasting. The overview of fire damage restoration explains why systeco relies on vacuum blasting without water and without chemicals.

On which surfaces does vacuum blasting work after a fire?

According to systeco, on clinker, concrete, plaster, natural stone and tiles, as well as on ceilings and wood. The blasting media table names the suitable medium.

How quickly can an area be cleaned?

For fire damage restoration, systeco states roughly 2 to 5 square metres per hour. The actual performance depends on the surface, the degree of soot and the set-up.

Is restoration possible during ongoing operations?

Because soot and blasting medium stay in the closed circuit and no wastewater is produced, sections can be worked on. The page fire damage restoration at running operation describes jobs.

Who pays for soot removal after a fire?

According to systeco, in most cases the building insurance covers the cost of fire damage restoration; where third parties are affected, the liability insurance of the party responsible may step in. The insurer clarifies the individual case.